Publication Ethics
1. Duties of Authors
Originality & Plagiarism
Authors must ensure that their work is entirely original. Any use of others' work must be appropriately cited. Plagiarism in all forms — including paraphrasing without attribution, duplicate publication, or data fabrication — constitutes unethical conduct and is not acceptable.
Multiple / Concurrent Submission
Authors must not simultaneously submit the same manuscript to more than one journal. Submitting the same work to multiple journals is unethical and unacceptable. Previously published work — in whole or in part — must not be resubmitted.
Authorship (ICMJE Criteria)
Authorship must be based on all four ICMJE criteria: (A) substantial contribution to conception or design, or data acquisition/analysis; (B) drafting or critically revising the work; (C) final approval; and (D) accountability for all aspects. Ghost and gift authorship are prohibited.
Author changes after submission are not permitted without documented justification and approval from all co-authors.
Data Integrity & Reproducibility
Authors must present accurate, unaltered data. Fabrication, falsification, or selective manipulation of data constitutes research misconduct. Authors should retain raw data for at least 5 years after publication and provide it upon reasonable editorial request.
Conflict of Interest Disclosure
All authors must disclose any financial or personal relationships that could be perceived as influencing their work. This includes employment, consultancies, stock ownership, honoraria, grants, patents, and other financial interests relevant to the submitted manuscript.
Errors in Published Work
If an author discovers a significant error in their published work, they must promptly notify the Editor-in-Chief and cooperate fully to issue an erratum, corrigendum, or retraction as appropriate. Authors should not delay or obstruct this process.
Human & Animal Research Ethics
All research involving human subjects must have been approved by an appropriate institutional ethics committee (Komite Etik Penelitian Kesehatan / KEPK) and conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki (WMA, 2013). Authors must state the name of the ethics committee, approval number, and date in the Methods section.
Informed consent must be obtained from all human participants or their legal guardians. For case reports involving identifiable patients, written consent must be obtained and stated in the manuscript. Patient identifiers must be anonymized unless consent for publication is explicitly provided.
Research involving animals must follow applicable national and international guidelines for animal welfare. The relevant ethics approval must be stated. Clinical trials must be registered in an internationally recognized registry (e.g., ClinicalTrials.gov, ANZCTR) prior to participant enrollment, per ICMJE requirements.
2. Duties of Editors
Fair Editorial Decisions
Editorial decisions are based solely on the scientific merit, originality, clarity, and relevance of the manuscript to the journal's scope. Decisions are never influenced by the authors' nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, or any other personal characteristic.
Confidentiality
Editors must treat all submitted manuscripts as confidential documents. Manuscript content must not be disclosed to any third party other than the assigned reviewers, without the explicit permission of the authors.
Editor Conflict of Interest
Editors must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts in which they have a conflict of interest — including submissions from close collaborators, supervisors, students, family members, or submissions related to the editor's own research area where bias may arise.
Investigating Misconduct
Editors must take reasonable measures to investigate suspected misconduct — including plagiarism, duplicate submission, or ethical violations — using COPE flowcharts as guidance. Editors must not dismiss such concerns without thorough investigation.
3. Duties of Peer Reviewers
Promptness & Accountability
Reviewers who accept an invitation must complete their review within the agreed time frame. If unable to complete the review, they must notify the Editor promptly so that an alternative reviewer can be assigned. Unnecessary delays are not acceptable.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts received for review are privileged and confidential documents. Reviewers must not share, discuss, or disclose any content of the manuscript with any third party during or after the review process without explicit editorial permission.
Objectivity
Reviews must be conducted objectively. Personal criticism of the authors is not appropriate. Opinions must be expressed clearly with supporting arguments. Reviewers must disclose any potential conflict of interest and decline review when such conflict exists.
Recognizing Relevant Work
Reviewers should identify published work not cited by the authors that supports or contradicts the claims made. Reviewers must alert the Editor to any substantial similarity between the manuscript under review and any other published paper of which they are aware.
4. Generative AI in Publishing — Ethical Policy (COPE 2023)
AI Cannot Be Listed as an Author
AI and AI-assisted tools (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Claude, etc.) cannot be listed as authors or co-authors of any manuscript. Authorship requires accountability and the ability to consent — which AI systems cannot fulfill. Any manuscript found to list an AI as author will be rejected or retracted.
Mandatory Disclosure of AI Use
Authors who used AI tools at any stage of manuscript preparation must disclose this in the manuscript. The disclosure must be placed in the Methods section (if used in research tasks) or in the Acknowledgments (if used for language editing or formatting), and must specify:
- Name and version of the AI tool used
- Specific task(s) performed by the AI
- Section(s) of the manuscript where AI was applied
Authors Bear Full Responsibility
Authors are fully responsible for the accuracy and integrity of all AI-assisted content. AI-generated text must be reviewed, verified, and take full scientific responsibility by the authors before submission. Authors may not use the involvement of AI as a defense against allegations of errors, fabrication, or misconduct.
AI-Generated References Must Be Verified
AI tools are known to produce hallucinated or non-existent references. Authors must individually verify every reference cited in the manuscript against the original source. Submitting fabricated or unverified AI-generated references constitutes research misconduct.
Undisclosed AI use constitutes a breach of publication ethics. Manuscripts found to contain undisclosed AI-generated content will be subject to rejection, retraction, or referral to the authors' institution depending on the severity. PedSciJ uses AI-content detection tools as part of its editorial screening process.
5. Research Misconduct & Sanctions
PedSciJ takes all forms of research misconduct seriously. Cases of suspected misconduct are investigated following COPE guidelines and flowcharts. Misconduct includes, but is not limited to:
Plagiarism
Data fabrication or falsification
Duplicate / redundant publication
Ghost / gift authorship
Undisclosed conflicts of interest
Ethical violations (no IRB approval)
Undisclosed AI-generated content
Reviewer confidentiality breach
Depending on the severity and stage of discovery, sanctions may include: rejection of the manuscript, retraction with public notice, notification of the author's institution, and/or a ban from future submissions to PedSciJ.
6. Corrections, Errata & Retractions
Erratum
Issued when the journal has introduced a significant error in the published work (e.g., typographical, formatting, or editorial errors). The original article remains in the record.
Corrigendum
Issued when authors identify significant errors in the published work that affect the accuracy but not the core conclusions. Authors must request this promptly upon discovery.
Retraction
Issued when findings are unreliable due to misconduct or honest error, or when results have been previously published elsewhere, or when the research constitutes an ethical violation. Retractions are permanent, prominently noted, and follow COPE Retraction Guidelines.
Expression of Concern
Issued when an investigation is ongoing and there are reasonable concerns about the integrity of the published work but a definitive conclusion has not yet been reached. It alerts readers while maintaining due process.
This policy is governed by