COPE 2023 · ICMJE 2023 · WAME 2023

Generative AI Policy

PedSciJ has adopted a comprehensive policy on the use of Generative AI and Large Language Models (LLMs) in manuscript preparation, peer review, and editorial processes — aligned with current international guidelines.

Updated 2024 Applies to Authors Applies to Reviewers Applies to Editors

Policy Overview

Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools — including but not limited to ChatGPT, GPT-4, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Llama, and Midjourney — present both opportunities and significant risks for scholarly publishing. PedSciJ recognizes that AI can assist in certain legitimate tasks, but its misuse poses fundamental threats to research integrity, transparency, and accountability.

This policy is informed by the position statements of COPE (2023), ICMJE (2023), and WAME (2023), and applies to all parties interacting with PedSciJ — authors, reviewers, and editors.

1. Core Principles

 

AI Cannot Be an Author

AI tools do not meet the ICMJE authorship criteria — they cannot take responsibility for the work, cannot consent to submission, and cannot be held accountable for errors. Listing any AI tool as an author or co-author will result in immediate rejection or retraction.

 

Disclosure is Mandatory

Any use of AI in the preparation of a manuscript — for writing, editing, data analysis, image generation, translation, or any other purpose — must be explicitly disclosed in the manuscript. Concealing AI use is a breach of publication ethics.

 

Human Accountability Always

Authors bear full and sole responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of all content in their manuscript — including any AI-generated or AI-assisted content. "The AI wrote it" is never an acceptable defense against misconduct allegations.

2. Policy for Authors

Permitted — With Mandatory Disclosure

Language & Grammar Editing

Using tools like Grammarly, ChatGPT, or DeepL to improve grammar, spelling, and language clarity — not to generate scientific content.

Literature Search Assistance

Using AI to help identify relevant literature, organize search results, or summarize abstracts — not as a substitute for critical reading.

Translation Assistance

Using AI translation tools (DeepL, ChatGPT) for manuscripts originally written in a non-English language — authors must verify accuracy.

Data Visualization

Using AI-assisted tools to help generate figures or statistical visualizations — must be disclosed and the underlying data must be verifiable.

Not Permitted — Grounds for Rejection or Retraction

AI-Written Scientific Content

Using AI to generate the Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, or Abstract without author-written oversight and full accountability.

AI-Fabricated References

Submitting references generated by AI without individual verification against the original source. AI hallucinated references constitute research fraud.

AI-Fabricated Data or Images

Presenting AI-generated images, figures, or data as if they were obtained from actual research. This constitutes data fabrication.

Concealment of AI Use

Using AI in any capacity without declaring it in the manuscript. Undisclosed AI use will be treated as a breach of publication ethics per COPE 2023.

How to Declare AI Use in Your Manuscript

The AI disclosure statement must specify:

Tool Name & Version

e.g., ChatGPT-4o (OpenAI, May 2024)

Task Performed

Specific function, e.g., grammar editing

Section(s) Affected

Which part of the manuscript

Where to Place It

Methods (research tasks) or Acknowledgments (editing)

Example Disclosure Statement

"ChatGPT-4o (OpenAI, accessed May 2024) was used to assist with grammar and language editing of the final manuscript draft. Grammarly Premium was used for spell-checking throughout the manuscript. No AI tool was used to generate scientific content, data, or conclusions. All content, reasoning, and claims are the sole responsibility of the authors."

3. Policy for Peer Reviewers

Reviewers May Use AI For

  • Grammar checking of the review text
  • Organizing or formatting reviewer comments
  • Literature search for identifying missing references
  • Translation assistance (with verification)

Reviewers Must NOT

  • Upload any part of the manuscript to any AI tool
  • Use AI to generate the review or the recommendation
  • Use AI to assess statistics or replicate analysis without expert judgment
  • Submit AI-generated review text without disclosure

Confidentiality Warning: Submitting any part of a manuscript to a public AI tool (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, etc.) constitutes a serious breach of reviewer confidentiality under COPE guidelines. Reviewers found to have done so may be permanently removed from PedSciJ's reviewer panel.

4. Policy for Editors

Editors may use AI tools to assist with administrative tasks such as:

  • Formatting correspondence templates
  • Summarizing editorial statistics or workflow data
  • Grammar and language checking of editorial communications

Editors must not use AI tools to make editorial decisions, assess manuscripts, generate reviewer recommendations, or upload any submitted manuscript content to AI platforms.

5. AI Content Detection at PedSciJ

PedSciJ may use AI-content detection tools as part of its initial editorial screening process. A high AI-content score alone is not grounds for rejection — editors review flagged manuscripts in context, considering the author's disclosure statement and the nature of the detected content. However, manuscripts that score high on AI-content detection and do not disclose any AI use will be treated as a potential breach of publication ethics and investigated accordingly.

This policy is based on

COPE Position on AI (2023) ICMJE Authorship Criteria (2023) WAME AI Statement (2023) Nature Portfolio AI Policy Springer Nature AI Policy